Tourism and Conservation: Rethinking the Paradigm


Due to its sheer size and potential, sustainable tourism — travel that attempts to benefit a destination’s economy, environment, and society — has become an essential element of nearly any economic development strategy in emerging economies around the world.

You’ve probably seen the stats: Worldwide, travel and tourism contribute 10.2 percent of GDP, are third in global exports (trailing only fuel and chemicals), create one in 10 jobs, and have outpaced the global economy in terms of growth for the sixth consecutive year in 2016.

But that’s primarily in mainstream destinations like Western Europe and North America, right?

Wrong. 2015 marked the first time in modern history that middle- and low-income countries received more visitors than the developed world — a whopping 550 million people going on safaris in Africa, exploring the Amazon in dugout canoes, and visiting ancient shrines in Asia.

But how much money are they really spending? In 2015, tourists spent $486 billion dollars in emerging economies — about three times the amount of official development assistance that year. Still not impressed? How about the fact that tourism is the number one source of foreign exchange in 83 percent of emerging economies.

In other words, if you’re doing economic development work in emerging economies and not seriously considering tourism as a part of your strategy, you’re missing the dugout canoe.

Yet while sustainable tourism, as a niche market, grows three times faster than the tourism industry overall, the unrelenting expansion of mass tourism’s all-inclusive resorts and ever-larger cruise ships continues to threaten the world’s fragile ecosystems, particularly in the coastal and marine destinations favored by sand and sun seekers. The result has been a loss of coastal mangrove and reef habitats, competition for fresh water and scarce resources, and social problems such as rising real estate prices and the displacement of fishing and farming communities.

The origins of sustainable tourism

It’s no secret that ecotourism, which in turn evolved into sustainable tourism, was born out of the conservation movement. International NGOs like Conservation International and The Nature Conservancy poured considerable resources into the ecotourism boom of the '80s and '90s. The concept was sexy and the opportunities seemed limitless.

But that interest and investment began to ebb about a decade ago — most likely due in part to the lack of success stories or replicable models illustrating how tourism could reduce biodiversity threats, not just contribute to them. These early challenges are likely due to an underestimation of the complexity and demands of a service-driven industry like tourism, and the inability of governments, development agencies, and NGOs to empower indigenous groups and community tourism micro-, small-, and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) with the unique skill sets it takes to meet the expectations of international travelers.

Sustainable tourism 2.0

Have we learned from those noble yet unsuccessful attempts to link tourism, poverty alleviation, and biodiversity conservation? Is there a chance to turn the (cruise) ship around?

You bet. First, sustainable tourism businesses need to run in the black in order to contribute to triple-bottom-line results like environmental protection and cultural preservation. That means in-depth market analysis and business planning, strong connectivity to industry partners like tour operators, innovative products and marketing, and world-class customer service developed through specialized training programs.

Second, we need to be more strategic in how we design sustainable tourism projects and create direct linkages between tourism job creation and biodiversity threat reduction. As part of the USAID Management of Aquatic Resources and Economic Alternatives (MAREA) project, my work with organizations like Solimar International and Chemonics International included documenting and disseminating replicable case studies that showcase tourism-based biodiversity threat reduction models that included identifying and training sea turtle poachers to transition to better-paying jobs as naturalist guides, developing and branding souvenirs like handbags made out of the same plastic bags littering beaches, and promoting best practices with tourists and codes of conduct with tour operators.

Third, we need to take both a bottom-up and a top-down approach. MSMEs account for over 90 percent of all businesses and 60 to 70 percent of total employment worldwide (numbers that are even higher in emerging economies). Clearly, we need to engage local tourism enterprises to have an impact. Yet we certainly can’t forget about the big guys either.

The World Wildlife Fund's Global Marine Programme estimates that coastal development, primarily development driven by mass tourism, is second only to unsustainable fishing as the primary threat to the world’s coastal and marine ecosystems. Through internationally recognized certification bodies like the Global Sustainable Tourism Criteria, major players in the industry (including Royal Caribbean Cruises, Airbnb and TUI Travel Group) are adopting environmentally sustainable policies to better manage water, waste, and electricity and reduce their overall footprint. And today, we are seeing such green certification programs not only for hotels, but also for parks, beaches, tour operators, guides, golf courses, marinas, and most recently, vacation homes.

Finally, we must divert more of the 10.2 percent of global GDP that tourism generates into local efforts to conserve the natural and cultural resources upon which the industry depends. In Belize, a $3.75 departure tax goes directly to the Protected Area Conservation Trust, a Belizean fund dedicated to the conservation of the Mesoamerican reef and rainforest. It is a small price to pay, yet since its inception in 1997, the tax has pumped nearly $17 million into protecting the country’s natural resources and maintaining its position as a world-class tourism destination.

What's next?

With all these great trends and opportunities, what’s the best thing we have going for us? The answer is market demand.

I could throw out a lot of statistics to prove my point, but unless you’ve been living under a rock, you’re probably aware of the fact that — from millennials to baby boomers — people are choosing their travel destinations and service providers more wisely. No longer is that little card in the bathroom about hanging up your towels enough. Travelers seek out tour operators and hotels that proudly offer carbon-neutral itineraries, authentic exchange with local communities that improves everyone’s day, and experiences that deliver those triple bottom line results.

As Luigi Cabrini, director for sustainable development at the U.N. World Tourism Organization nicely summarized, “The tourism sector is embracing responsible tourism not as an option, but as a condition for its continuous growth.”

Matthew Humke has worked for 20 years in Latin America, Africa, and Asia for organizations like Rare and Solimar International developing sustainable tourism as a tool for economic development and biodiversity conservation. The tourism enterprises Matthew has helped to establish, such as La Ruta Moskitia in Honduras, have generated more than $5 million for local economies. The success of these enterprises has resulted in a number of the industry’s top honors, including a World Travel & Tourism Council “Tourism for Tomorrow” award. Matthew is the author of the Sustainable Tourism Toolkit, a four-part publication designed to help local entrepreneurs and project managers, particularly in developing countries, successfully develop sustainable tourism. For more information, please contact Matthew Humke at matthewhumke@gmail.com.

Leave a Comment

3 Questions with Maria Olanda Bata: Withstanding Storms in Mozambique


Maria Olanda Bata is the chief of party of the USAID Mozambique Coastal Cities Adaptation Project (CCAP) and a food security, early warning, and disaster risk reduction specialist. CCAP works with vulnerable coastal cities in Mozambique to improve their resilience to climate variations and extreme weather. What are the biggest risks if cities in Mozambique do not become more resilient? It would be a catastrophe. Right now, we’re starting to see the impact of extreme climate events, and we know they...

Read More »

New Report Synthesizes Evidence on Climate Risks to Health in Africa


This blog post originally appeared on Climatelinks. Thanks to aggressive interventions in recent decades, remarkable progress has been made across sub-Saharan Africa in reducing child mortality, malaria deaths, and stunting rates, and improving overall health. But these gains may be lost as climate and weather variability put more people at risk of infection and death from climate-sensitive diseases. In East Africa alone, for example, malaria infection rates are expected to rise with 45 to 65...

Read More »

Building a Stronger Business Case for Resiliency Planning in Asia


The landmark 21st Conference of Parties (COP21) Paris Agreement recognized the need for a multi-pronged approach to reach the ambitious development goals set by 195 countries, 34 of which are in Asia. With one-third of the world’s total population, Asia is increasingly vulnerable to climate change due to its low-lying, heavily populated coastlines and dependency on agricultural exports. The global economic loss in the Asian markets attributed to natural disasters is astounding. In 2016,...

Read More »

Can Ocean Temperature Changes Forecast Malaria Transmission in Southern Africa?


This blog post originally appeared on ClimateLinks. In backpacking across Africa as a recent college graduate, James Colborn felt drawn to the place and the people and wanted to do more than just travel around as a tourist. Soon after, he found his calling in global health. Today, Colborn has a Ph.D. in parasitology and years of experience working on malaria in sub-Saharan Africa with organizations ranging from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to the Clinton Health...

Read More »

How a Small City Can Take on the Big Challenge of Conservation Financing


By Jana Franke-Everett and Anselmo Cabrera Negros, the fourth-largest island in the Philippines, is best known for sugar and grilled chicken. However, the charcoal that fuels restaurant owners’ income challenges the source of livelihood for rice and sugar farmers. What is the link between a tasty grilled chicken and a cup of rice? Well, the demand for charcoal puts pressure on the island’s remaining natural forest that protects the watersheds because the forests in the uplands are a common source...

Read More »

Is “Secure Enough” Good Enough for Land Tenure? A Case Study from Rwanda


By Michael Brown and Ailey Kaiser Hughes What is “secure enough” tenure? The concept of “secure enough” tenure has been discussed in the context of humanitarian and post-disaster programming and increasingly through donor initiatives. In our new paper, we adopt the following definition of secure enough tenure, established by USAID: “[T]he benchmark of tenure security [is] when rights to land and natural resources are not arbitrarily contested by the state, private entities, or others and that...

Read More »

Climate Information Services: Distilling Data into Informed Decision-Making


Climate information services (CIS) is the new acronym on the block in the global environment and climate resilience community. The Global Framework for Climate Services (GFCS) is the leading international advocate and authority on CIS. It was established in 2009 as a result of a U.N. initiative to support integrated international efforts for the development and uptake of CIS in support of decision-making. GFCS emphasizes that “climate is what you expect, and weather is what you get,” and defines...

Read More »

Local Government: A Channel for Action on Climate Adaptation


This blog post originally appeared on Climatelinks. New research in Mali highlights a promising opportunity for action on climate change adaptation: local government development planning. Tim Finan and Mamadou Baro of the University of Arizona presented results of a study supported by USAID’s Adaptation, Thought Leadership, and Assessments (ATLAS) project on January 12 at USAID’s monthly Adaptation Community Meeting. The study explored ways in which Mali’s 25-year-old decentralized...

Read More »

Bringing the Power of Google to Scientists in the Lower Mekong


This blog post was contributed by SERVIR, a joint initiative by NASA and USAID, and was originally posted on www.servirglobal.net. Landscapes on Earth are changing at unprecedented levels. For scientists, practitioners, and environmental decision makers, tracking these changes efficiently and accurately is critical to protecting lives and livelihoods. While there are many ways to learn about the dynamic nature of the Earth, satellite technology provides a unique perspective in observing our land,...

Read More »

Bringing Climate Science into Development Planning


This blog post is adapted from a post that originally appeared on Climatelinks. Climate science is a complex field, and communicating that science and its implications for development programming in a way that is clear, but does not oversimplify, is a persistent challenge. Yet bridging the gap between research and implementation is vital for development practitioners to understand the variables that projected climate changes may introduce into their planning across sectors, and for them to manage...

Read More »

In Focus: The Calm Before the Storm


Before a natural disaster hits in the United States, most Americans learn about incoming dangerous weather events through mobile phone weather apps, weather websites, radios, and televisions. But in many developing countries, people are often unprepared when a storm hits. The consequences can be dire. In a country that is particularly vulnerable to natural disasters, damages caused by flooding are expected to cost Mozambique approximately $45 million by 2030, and caused more than 2,000 deaths...

Read More »

A Paradigm Shift is Necessary for REDD+ to Be Sustainable


In 2013 I wrote a book called Redeeming REDD: Policies, Incentives, and Social Feasibility for Avoided Deforestation, published by Earthscan. In the book I argue that reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation (REDD, and the latest variant known as REDD+), needs a suite of enabling conditions, independent of market viability as well as measurement, reporting and verification (MRV) systems in order to be redeemed as an effective approach. REDD projects, it was hoped, would feed...

Read More »

Wildlife and Plant Trafficking – Is Prohibition the Only Answer?


A few weeks after the CITES COP17, which took place earlier this month in Johannesburg, I am left wondering: What impact will the increased prohibitions on the international trade of endangered animal and plant products have? And how will the rural African communities I work with, who deal with dangerous wild animals, see the agreements? The key question for any assessment of CITES is whether prohibition is the answer to the problem of illegal trade in endangered species. It looked to me like...

Read More »

Diffusing Land-Use Conflict with Science and Transparency


The challenge of equitable and efficient land allocation Land-use decision making forces politicians and land managers to grapple with choices that pit one interest group against another, and every decision seems destined to create conflict. But what if potential land uses could be ranked and supported by science? Are there win-win scenarios out there, waiting to be discovered? In the Okavango River Basin, one approach is doing just that. The Land-Use Conflict Identification Strategy, or LUCIS, is...

Read More »

Meet 3 Animals that Tell Us About the Health of the Philippines' Forests


Some animals that depend on the forest tell us a great deal about the health of their environment and the effectiveness of efforts to preserve it. In the Philippines, environmentalists and government officials are using a new system called the LAWIN Forest and Biodiversity Protection System to monitor the state of forests in an unprecedented way – among other things, collecting data on the presence of forest-dependent species.  The Philippines' vanishing forests Like many developing countries, the...

Read More »

3 Questions with Mozambican Mayors: Local Perspectives on Climate Change Resilience


Manuel de Araujo, Tagir Carimo, and Rui Chong Saw are the mayors of Quelimane, Pemba, and Nacala — three coastal cities in Mozambique that are struggling with the effects of climate change. The mayors are collaborating with USAID/Mozambique’s Coastal City Adaptation Project, a five-year project aiming to increase the cities’ capacity to effectively respond to the impacts of climate change.  Do you feel that climate change is impacting your city? If so, what is the day-to-day impact? Tagir Carimo:...

Read More »

5 Considerations for Measuring Resilience


Mainstreaming resilience has catapulted to the top of the development agenda in recent years. It is now an integral part of climate change strategies at the local, national, and international level. Resilience, once a secondary outcome, has become a principal objective in designing and measuring the results of both climate adaptation and mitigation in addition to poverty reduction programming. The recent Adaptation Futures Conference in May, which featured several sessions on measuring...

Read More »

What the Paris Agreement Means for the Sustainable Development Goals


The signing of the Paris Climate Agreement today, on Earth Day, represents a global consensus that climate change has, and will continue, to fundamentally alter our natural systems and challenge our way of life unless we take collective and measured steps towards a carbon neutral path. Significantly, it comes on the heels of another monumental international agreement that recognizes the importance of climate change – the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Climate change and poverty are...

Read More »

Benefiting Equally from Land – Reaching Women Before It’s Too Late


The timing, approach, and pace of land reform and collective farm restructuring throughout the former Soviet republics has varied dramatically – and in many places is still ongoing. Whether government chose to privatize land, guarantee land use rights, or keep the status quo of state ownership, land and access to it remains critical for millions of citizens who rely on the land for their livelihoods. Land challenges faced by those throughout Europe and Eurasia is very similar to tens of millions...

Read More »