Refugees Are Straining Urban Infrastructure and Services — Now What?

More people live in cities now than at any point in history. As identified in Sustainable Development Goal 11 and highlighted in the New Urban Agenda formulated out of the Habitat III Conference last year, our challenge is to make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient, and sustainable. Goal 11 and the New Urban Agenda identify a number of key issues, including transportation, disaster response, environmental change and green growth, resilient infrastructure, and access to safe and affordable housing.

The refugee crisis means urban development is more important than ever

In some parts of the world, refugee crises due to political violence and climate change compound the challenge of making cities safe and equitable. With more refugees settling in urban areas, humanitarian organizations like the office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) have come to recognize the role cities can play in fostering greater freedom of movement and independence for refugees than traditional camp settings. At the same time, urban infrastructure, service delivery, and natural resources can become severely strained. Urban refugees may experience difficulties accessing basic services and housing and also confront social marginalization, acts of discrimination, and exploitation. Host communities also become more vulnerable, particularly as housing and labor markets become distorted.

Smart technologies and systems can help ensure that urban infrastructure development and service delivery improvements produce sustainable and resilient results. Smart technologies and systems can also improve the quality of urban life by acknowledging the shared urban experiences of refugee and host communities and fostering opportunities for strengthened community relationships. The following four points outline important considerations for harnessing the impact of smart systems in creating safe, equitable, and resilient cities for all people.

Smart cities require inclusive planning processes

Urban refugees live among their host community neighbors. Their children attend the same schools, they shop in the same markets, and they experience the same daily frustrations with poor service delivery and infrastructure. Urban refugees also have immediate humanitarian needs that need to be met. For a variety of reasons, including the uncertain future of refugee families, humanitarian crises may change urban planning priorities and perhaps delay or sideline plans to invest in smart systems. However, the goals of development programs and humanitarian responses do not need to be mutually exclusive. Smart city development and investment plans can account for the needs of refugee communities specifically as well as urban residents more broadly. In many cases, however, accounting for refugee needs in urban planning processes is politically sensitive. Stakeholder engagement, transparency, and coordination between donors and national and municipal governments can help facilitate inclusivity and consensus. By aligning municipal development priorities with humanitarian response needs, cities can harness the benefits of smart systems and improve the urban experience for all residents.

Smart cities require smart systems

Urban refugees may increase demand for services and stress on infrastructure, resulting in peak crises sooner than anticipated. In many cities around the world, service providers have large budget deficits, resource scarcity concerns, and growing infrastructure investment needs. These challenges are interrelated. Infrastructure may be underground and out of sight, expensive and susceptible to rapid depreciation, and vulnerable to damage from climate change or vandalism. Smart technologies, such as smart grids and geographic information systems, can generate better data for planning and decision-making for infrastructure development and service delivery improvements. With mapping programs, cities can improve public health by identifying safer locations for solid waste processing centers and more efficient transportation routes for solid waste vehicles. Similarly, smart meters and billing systems can help utility engineers to quickly identify and respond to resource losses in the municipal water network and improve customer service response processes. Smart technologies can help cities ensure the sustainable impact of investments to improve infrastructure and service delivery and, in turn, improve quality of life for urban residents including refugees.

Smart cities require smart service delivery providers

Investments in smart technologies for infrastructure and service delivery require trained engineers and managers. Training programs are crucial to the successful investment, installation, and use of smart technologies. Municipal staff may require training in the use of software programs, the operation of new technologies, and maintenance or troubleshooting skills. Experts developing training curricula should seek buy-in and participation from government counterparts, local and international experts familiar with best practices, and universities and training institutions. If possible, training programs should be accredited to encourage participation and improve employment prospects for beneficiaries. Additionally, programs should seek to train engineers and managers to adapt the use of new technologies to changes in the built environment and social dynamics. This will ensure that the technologies do not become obsolete as conditions change, that future planning initiatives yield sustainable results, and that crisis response systems remain effective. By understanding how to operate, provide maintenance, and troubleshoot in times of emergency, service delivery providers will be more effectively equipped to respond to their customers and provide more equitable and transparent services.

Smart cities require community involvement

Households can play an important role in creating safe, inclusive, and resilient cities. Municipal authorities and the development community should work with households and neighborhood organizations to understand their needs, hear their suggestions, and collaboratively assess opportunities for innovative and targeted neighborhood and household investment programs. Urban residents are strongly positioned to identify strategic infrastructure enhancements at the household and neighborhood level. For example, households may have suggestions for innovative recycling programs which can be scaled, or may already practice informal waste management which can be transformed into formalized livelihood opportunities. Similarly, households may also have suggestions for strategic investments which can help reduce monthly expenditures, such as water-saving devices, and tax credits or grants can help encourage the installation of energy saving devices, which will help reduce the financial burden on vulnerable households. Indeed, it is at the neighborhood level where we see refugee and host communities interacting the most. Collaborative engagement and strategic investments can help strengthen community bonds.

Urban refugee crises present a complex and dynamic challenge that requires innovative solutions to create safe, inclusive, and resilient cities. By investing in smart technologies and systems, and fostering inclusivity in the planning process, cities facing urban refugee crises can meet the goals set forth in Sustainable Development Goal 11 and the New Urban Agenda.

Basil Mahayni is a manager in the Water, Energy, and Sustainable Cities Practice, and has a Ph.D. in geography, environment, and society from the University of Minnesota – Twin Cities.

Leave a Comment

Why Privatization Has Not Improved Power Supply in Nigeria

This is a guest blog post that was originally posted on Ventures Africa. While gas shortages, inadequate transmission, and losses pose critical bottlenecks, the main challenge for the power sector in Nigeria is the lack of liquidity (or weak commercial viability) of actors along the value chain — from gas-to-power production to power generation, transmission, and distribution. Once there is sufficient flow of funds and a visible path to profitability, investments in improvements and expansion...

Read More »

Developing Countries Can Leapfrog Today's Urban Infrastructure

At the foundation of every city are the physical systems that deliver water and power, dispose of solid waste and sewage, transport people and commodities, and transmit communications. Delivery of these basic infrastructure services to exponentially growing populations is a massive technological, financial, and governance challenge in cities of the developing world. However, the lack of basic infrastructure in developing cities also presents a huge opportunity to bypass the conventional...

Read More »

World Water Day: Closing the Skills Gap for Better Water, Better Jobs in Water-Scarce Countries

Nearly all jobs are related to water. The UN emphasizes that sustainable development is contingent on adequate quality and quantity for public health and agricultural and economic development. Climate change strategies depend on the thousands of people who work in water to help transform societies by properly managing and operating utilities. While safe drinking water, sanitation, and wastewater management are crucial determinants for sustainable development, the UN has identified the need to...

Read More »

A Return to the Stage in Mozambique

Beyond the bamboo gate at Vitor Raposo’s cultural center in Pemba, Mozambique, a canopy of trees threaded with artwork and wind chimes welcomes me into a tranquil courtyard. Tambo Tambulani Tambo is a peaceful refuge, a stark contrast from nearby construction sites and spirals of soot rising from newly forged roads. With investors racing to build resorts and guesthouses along the city’s coastline to accommodate a recent economic boom — driven in part by the discovery of natural gas in the nearby...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: Your Guide to What the U.N. Is Doing This Weekend

Today, the United Nations Sustainable Development Summit opens in New York. More than 150 world leaders are expected to gather there to adopt the proposed Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), an ambitious document meant to define the world’s development agenda for the next 15 years. With 17 goals and 169 individual targets, the SDGs are more numerous and complex than their predecessor, the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), adopted in 2000. But they are hugely important, both individually and...

Read More »

The Road to Resilience: Lessons in Climate Change Adaptation from Two Mozambican Cities

As we approach summer here in the United States, many families have already started planning that dream get-away vacation to the beach. A trip to the beach melts away our worries as quickly as waves crash on the shore. For many people around the world though, these same waves both provide and threaten livelihoods. More than a billion people around the world make their homes in low-lying coastal areas, and with good reason: rivers and lakes provide clean water for cooking, bathing, agriculture,...

Read More »

3 Questions with Carlos E. Quintela on Climate Change Adaptation

Carlos E. Quintela leads the Mozambique Coastal City Adaptation Project—a five-year, $15 million effort to help municipal authorities in Mozambique understand and apply urban climate adaptation solutions, and increase local capacity to adapt to climate change. Today, Carlos joins other climate and development experts at the National Adaptation Forum in St. Louis, Missouri.  Q. Some people still talk about climate change as if it is a future threat, rather than something we are facing now. Is this...

Read More »

Live from World Water Week

Although the official theme at this year’s World Water Week, an annual development conference held in Stockholm, Sweden, is “Energy and Water,” from the first session the speakers have adopted food security as an unofficial pillar. Many of the conference seminars and workshops formally incorporate agricultural themes into their discussions, and USAID is no exception. Earlier this week, USAID announced the final list of awardees for its latest Grand Challenge for Development, the Securing Water...

Read More »