This Land is My Land: Securing Land Rights for Vulnerable Groups Through Responsible Governance

This week, hundreds of the world’s leading land rights scholars, practitioners, and governors will convene in our nation’s capital for the World Bank Land and Poverty Conference. The theme of this year’s conference is “Scaling up Responsible Land Governance,” and conference-goers will join forces to develop clear pathways for “working at scale, mainstreaming innovations, and sustaining investments in land governance.”

This month also marks another significant event in land rights history, as more than 300 individuals and organizations launched the Global Call to Action on Indigenous and Community Land Rights. The campaign has set an ambitious target of doubling the amount of land legally recognized as owned or controlled by indigenous peoples and communities by 2020. A veritable call to arms, the campaign aims to persuade national and local authorities, as well as private sector actors and influential national and international institutions to get serious about addressing the challenges posed by unclear land governance systems.

The confluence of these events is perhaps more symbolic that one might think. The two themes are irrevocably intertwined. In fact, if the global call to action is to really achieve its mandate of doubling the communally owned land that this legally recognized, responsible governance systems must be in place to uphold laws that protect the most vulnerable in society or reform them if such protections are not already in place.

What are the barriers to secure tenure rights for indigenous and vulnerable populations?

According to a 2015 baseline study by the Rights and Resources Initiative, communities and indigenous peoples are estimated to occupy as much as 65 percent of the world’s land area, but only 18 percent of that land is recognized as formally owned or designated for indigenous peoples or communities. And in many countries, though the law may provide for secure tenure regimes, in practice, governments and individuals alike struggle to ensure that such regimes are upheld.

Nowhere else is this complexity more evident than in sub-Saharan Africa, where some of the more progressive legal frameworks have been established to protect community land rights, and yet in reality, few smallholders have formal titles. In addition, the distinction between legal regimes that uphold formal ownership rights as opposed to those which only designate land for indigenous populations and communities is riddled with complexity.

In Mozambique, for instance, the National Land Policy and the 1997 Land Law uphold the customary tenure rights and privileges of rural communities and smallholder farmers, who may seek individualized title within a community held Direito de Uso e Aproveitamento dos Terras (leasehold) or through a land use right granted by the government. At the institutional level, however, land administration bodies lack the capacity and political will to implement the laws. Additionally, despite significant efforts to raise public awareness, many smallholder farmers remain unaware of their rights and almost universally lack the financial and technical means to secure their rights through formal registration.

Individualized land rights face even greater pressures in the name of economic development. Across the sub-Saharan landscape, governments keen on securing private investment have often granted large tracts of land to both national and international companies who wish to use the land for purposes such as commercial agriculture or biofuel production. An unfortunate number of those land deals occur on indigenous land without any consultation with the affected community, though in most cases such consultation is required by law, and when consultation does occur, communities are often ill-informed about how these investments will affect their land ownership.

In Tanzania, for example, as recent study found that in the case of a 32,000 hectare land acquisition by a foreign biofuels company, villagers were reported as saying that they thought they had only leased their land, and did not understand that their approval of the land acquisition would involve relinquishing their customary rights to the land.

How can responsible governance secure the rights of the vulnerable?

Doubling the amount of land that is legally recognized as owned by indigenous populations and communities is an achievable goal, provided that the global community can commit to the following:

  • Greater governmental accountability. Governments around the world need to undergo a systematic review of their existing legal frameworks, assess the need for reforms, and provide legal re cognition of individual and community land rights in the most expedient, and cost effective manner. The international community must hold governments accountable for carrying out such legal reviews independently and without bias.

  • Increased awareness. Donors, NGOs, and other development agencies should support land governance bodies in communicating critical elements of the legal framework governing land so that citizens may understand the both benefits of formalizing ownership and the process through which this may be achieved. Similarly, the development community should support land governance bodies to identify and eliminate unnecessary impediments to formal registration.

  • Large-scale governmental capacity building. Donors NGOs and other development agencies must also support large-scale governance capacity building initiatives based on an assessment of how those actors are implementing the laws currently. Incentives must be put in place that encourage land governance bodies to enforce the laws and uphold community land rights.

  • Inclusive land-based transactions. Private investors and governments must ensure that land-based transactions are conducted in consultation with affected communities and are in accordance with national and international best practices.

As with any major initiative the road ahead is quite long, but it’s clear that the demand is there. Now is the time to really put words into action, overcome business as usual, and uphold a rights-based and equitable approach to land ownership.

Erica Burdick is a member of Chemonics’ Environment and Natural Resources Practice and a manager in the East and Southern Africa Division, where she supports USAID’s Rwanda Land program.

Leave a Comment

Where Are the Barriers? Studying Climate Change Adaptation in Mali

Climate change makes life even harder for subsistence farmers and marginal populations. In the development field, we need to learn how to address tangible problems that block adoption of improved mechanisms. USAID’s Climate Change Adaptation Activity (CCAA) in Mali — a two-year intervention in the Mopti Region — has such an opportunity. In conjunction with our partners, the Humanitarian Response and Development Lab (HURDL) and Sahel Eco, we are undertaking an intense study of the socioeconomic...

Read More »

In Focus: Sustainable Livelihoods in Peru

In this photo, the owner of a small business in Ucayali, Peru, and an employee work with seeds from the Amazon rainforest. The business, Pro Mujer Oriente, employs 54 women to make handicrafts using tree materials. With the help of the Peru Environmental Management and Forest Governance Support Activity (Peru Bosques), Pro Mujer Oriente learned techniques to improve the quality of their handicrafts and organize their business more effectively. As a result, they have lowered their costs, increased...

Read More »

Adoption of the Paris Agreement: What Comes Next?

On December 12, 2015, the 21st Conference of Parties (COP21) for the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change concluded with 190 countries adopting the Paris Agreement. This historic agreement sets the path for the next phase of climate action. So what has concretely changed?  New ambition Throughout COP21, I was struck by the delegations’ strong determination and collective will to arrive at an ambitious agreement. The conference started off with opening remarks from 150 heads of...

Read More »

The Challenge of Measuring Climate Change Adaptation

Although the causes of climate change and the roles various nations must play in fighting it have been hotly debated, data provide solid evidence that our planet is facing significant climate challenges that impact our livelihoods, our well-being, and even our very lives. Addressing climate change requires a two-fold strategy: mitigation to deal with carbon emissions and adaption to deal with the effects of a changing climate. The world has made good progress with common measurements of climate...

Read More »

One Tool Every City That Is Vulnerable to Climate Change Should Have

Before COP 21 kicked off in Paris, heads of state from 20 countries who make up the Climate Vulnerable Forum adopted the Manila-Paris Declaration, which outlined concerns, priorities and plans for addressing climate change. The declaration enumerated how the threats we see in the news everyday — rising sea levels, cyclones, drought, and others — make these nations vulnerable to climate change. While geography influences how vulnerable nations, cities, and villages are to climate change,...

Read More »

3 Questions with Patrick Rader on Climate-Smart Agriculture

Patrick Rader leads the Feed the Future Uganda Commodity Production and Marketing Activity (CPM), which harnesses market forces and uses innovative methods to increase the productivity of Ugandan families. CPM reduces poverty and under-nutrition by increasing the quantity and quality of coffee, maize, and beans that rural families are able to produce and sell. Q. According to the World Bank, climate change could push more than 100 million people back into poverty over the next 15 years, primarily...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: Your Guide to What the U.N. Is Doing This Weekend

Today, the United Nations Sustainable Development Summit opens in New York. More than 150 world leaders are expected to gather there to adopt the proposed Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), an ambitious document meant to define the world’s development agenda for the next 15 years. With 17 goals and 169 individual targets, the SDGs are more numerous and complex than their predecessor, the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), adopted in 2000. But they are hugely important, both individually and...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: The Time is Now for Action on Climate Change

Over the past several years climate change has garnered increased attention around the globe, as everyone from farmers to politicians seek out ways to mitigate both the causes and effects of increased climate variability. The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) reflect this increased attention in SDG 13, which calls for urgent action to combat climate change and its impacts. Goal 13 goes on to include language about strengthening resilience to natural disasters, integrating climate change...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: Land Matters for Sustainable Development

Insecurity of land tenure and property rights is cited as a precipitating, if not primary, cause of contemporary global poverty and inequality. Research from a range of sources including the World Bank, the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization, OECD, civil society organizations, and academic institutions show that strengthening land and property rights goes hand in hand with the realization of development objectives related to poverty alleviation, food security, environmental...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: Can We Learn to Live Sustainably?

“With less than 5 percent of world population, the U.S. uses one-third of the world’s paper, a quarter of the world’s oil, 23 percent of the coal, 27 percent of the aluminum, and 19 percent of the copper… [and] a child born in the United States will create thirteen times as much ecological damage over the course of his or her lifetime than a child born in Brazil.” – Dave Tilford, the Sierra Club Despite the publicity that climate change, biodiversity loss and sustainability have increasingly...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: Valuing Forests and Other Terrestrial Ecosystems

As Eileen Hoffman observed in last week’s blog post on Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 1, the seventeen SDGs are interconnected and must be pursued concurrently. Poverty alleviation, food security, sustainable economic growth, gender equality — each goal contains ambitious targets, but it is the commitment to resilience and inclusivity enshrined across all the goals that weaves them together into a vision of the global agenda for the next 15 years or more. Scanning the goals in the context of...

Read More »

Know Your SDGs: All Hands on Deck for the World's Oceans

“I really don't know why it is that all of us are so committed to the sea, except I think it's because in addition to the fact that the sea changes, and the light changes, and ships change, it's because we all came from the sea. And it is an interesting biological fact that all of us have in our veins the exact same percentage of salt in our blood that exists in the ocean, and, therefore, we have salt in our blood, in our sweat, in our tears. We are tied to the ocean. And when we go back to the...

Read More »

The Road to Resilience: Lessons in Climate Change Adaptation from Two Mozambican Cities

As we approach summer here in the United States, many families have already started planning that dream get-away vacation to the beach. A trip to the beach melts away our worries as quickly as waves crash on the shore. For many people around the world though, these same waves both provide and threaten livelihoods. More than a billion people around the world make their homes in low-lying coastal areas, and with good reason: rivers and lakes provide clean water for cooking, bathing, agriculture,...

Read More »

Lessons from a Desert Island for World Environment Day

I will always be impressed as to how 4,000 inhabitants established their community on Hinnavaru—a paragon of desert islands in the Maldives. Hot sand, dust, and scarce vegetation combine to provide scant shade beneath the unrelenting equatorial sun. Somehow, every single vista on this island is overwhelmed by the Indian Ocean. On a recent visit, I felt trapped. The only thing preventing the ocean from swallowing the island up is a meter or two of elevation above the water level. I visited...

Read More »

In Focus: Creating Economic Opportunities While Conserving the Rainforest

In this photo, the owner of a small business in Ucayali, Peru, works with an employee to create a product using seeds from the Amazon rainforest. The business, Pro Mujer Oriente, employs 54 women to make handicrafts using tree materials. The Peru Environmental Management and Forest Governance Support Activity, or Peru Bosques Project, supported Pro Mujer Oriente to establish partnerships by participating in national trade fairs and to improve the appearance of its products. With...

Read More »

3 Questions with Carlos E. Quintela on Climate Change Adaptation

Carlos E. Quintela leads the Mozambique Coastal City Adaptation Project—a five-year, $15 million effort to help municipal authorities in Mozambique understand and apply urban climate adaptation solutions, and increase local capacity to adapt to climate change. Today, Carlos joins other climate and development experts at the National Adaptation Forum in St. Louis, Missouri.  Q. Some people still talk about climate change as if it is a future threat, rather than something we are facing now. Is this...

Read More »

Earth Day 2015: How Can All Development Programs Work Toward a Sustainable Planet?

Chemonics launched its first development project in 1975, just five years after the first Earth Day rallies in 1970 sparked the modern environmental movement. Since then, the company has implemented more than 200 projects in biodiversity conservation, natural resource management, climate change adaptation, and related areas. Certainly, Chemonics’ commitment to building healthier human-nature interactions was a draw for me when I joined the company. Although I’m a historian of Latin America by...

Read More »

Dispatch from Sydney: The World Parks Congress

"Whose gonna stand up to the big machine?" Stand up to fossil fuels. End fracking now! Who's gonna stand up and save the earth?” This was the final refrain of the youth delegation at the World Parks Congress. It was sung in front of several thousand odd people, to by and large a strong ovation. Youth, primarily from northern/western countries, played somewhat of an outsized role at the Congress’ large plenary presentations, which supported the strong theme of IUCN in its organization of the Congress...

Read More »

Promoting Inclusive Governance from the Land Up

The count of African countries supposedly increased by one in June, when a Virginia man planted a flag in the disputed territory of Bir Tawil and claimed himself king of “North Sudan.” He based his claim on the doctrine of terra nullius, "land not under the sovereignty of any state." The news article was something of a novelty piece, and despite posing a challenge to the region’s previous soi-disant ruler, the claim is dependent on legal recognition from the United Nations and other entities...

Read More »