Predicting Human Rights Violations Before They Happen

In 2000, Colombia was besieged by what had been one of the most violent decades in the history of its armed internal conflict. The rise and consolidation of paramilitary groups throughout the country that had begun as a self-protection movement against the guerrillas were out of control, and Colombia saw some of the worst human rights violations with millions of internally displaced persons and almost 2,000 massacres between 1980 and 2012 that left 11,700 people dead.

In response to public outcry in the regions that many of these violations could have been prevented, and the emergence of trends leading to massacres and massive displacements (such as the appearance of armed men in uniform, pamphlets with threats against community leaders, and selective homicides), the Ombudsman’s Office sought help from the U.S. government to create an early warning system that could respond to this humanitarian emergency by equipping the government with tools to raise alerts of impending human rights violations.

For 12 years, USAID supported the development of the early warning system to its current state of over 50 permanent staff that continuously monitor the country. In 2012, Chemonics began working with USAID to ensure the safety of human rights defenders and communities across Colombia, in part by improving the early warning system. What we found was that despite the system being consolidated, it relied heavily on communities. We also saw an opportunity to better educate local authorities about how to collect and interpret data that would allow them to track and prevent human rights violations, even in regions where the incidence of these crimes was historically high.

As a response, we developed a threat analysis framework through which authorities are able to identify variables contributing to degrading circumstances and human rights violations. This model will allow for systematic data collection and the interpretation of risk and security by pairing community-based cartography with existing databases using four main variables:

  • Territorial dynamics. The territorial dynamics variable aims to understand the use of the territory and its resources and to pinpoint areas with the highest degree of violence.

  • Dynamics of violence. This variable describes armed groups, including their objectives, capacity to control the population, areas under their control, the type of violence they use.

  • Institutional capacity. Institutional capacity refers to the types of institutions in a territory, their coordination and response capacity, political motivations of elected officials to stop or allow violence, and resources to prevent violations and protect victims or at-risk populations.

  • Populations at risk. This variable examines which populations are present, their degree of vulnerability to violence, and their organizational and representational capacity, as well as specific threats that they have received or situations and conditions that place them at a higher risk compared to the overall population (for example, identifying a public soccer field where children are being forcibly recruited).

The risk and security information management methodology walks public officials through the process of understanding the implications of conflict in human security and the risks related to human rights, understanding the underlying factors through four main variables, making those variables even more concrete through the use of indicators and superimposing geo-referenced maps with social mapping. All of these risk-mapping tools flag for authorities the areas at imminent risk and where human rights violations are most likely to occur while identifying specific at-risk populations, such as journalists, women, ethnic communities, LGBTI, and youth.

This methodology allows for a more complete picture of the risks involved to different populations in a given territory and local officials are also better able to plan and mobilize resources to contain the sources of threats and human rights abuses within their territory. By emphasizing the importance of including the communities as an analytical variable, it also promotes dialogue between them and local authorities. It also empowers communities by giving them a chance to analyze their own threats and vulnerabilities, by giving them a voice and by encouraging them to make a shift from being a passive subject to an active stakeholder that is better equipped to take action in reducing those vulnerabilities and thus contributing to its own protection.

This shift in the way that prevention is understood from a national responsibility to an emphasis on local capacities will be key in the upcoming years in Colombia. It is expected that better understanding at the local level will elicit better informed and more immediate response to the new challenges that may arise from a potential peace agreement with the FARC and possibly the ELN. Although the agreement would eliminate the internal conflict, challenges remain to find flexible and adaptable tools to these new scenarios capable of protecting communities from new and rising threats so that the country is finally able to reap the seeds of peace.

Laura Zambrano is Chemonics’ deputy chief of party for the USAID Colombia Human Rights Program. The program builds the capacity of the Colombian government and civil society to prevent and respond to human rights violations.

Leave a Comment

3 Questions with Lainie Reisman: Preventing Crime and Violence in Mexico's Roughest Places

Lainie Reisman is a youth violence expert with 15 years of experience in development. She is currently Chemonics' chief of party for the USAID Prevención de la Violencia (JPV) project in Mexico. JPV is designed to strengthen the Mexican government’s ability, from the federal to municipal levels, to prevent crime and violence. JPV also works closely with civil society, the private sector, and academia. Your program is working in Juarez, Monterrey, and Tijuana, and other areas selected in part...

Read More »

What Could the Trans-Pacific Partnership Mean for International Development?

The Trans-Pacific Partnership is the biggest regional trade agreement in history. Twelve countries representing nearly 40 percent of the world’s GDP — Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore, the United States, and Vietnam — have agreed on a trade pact that will link their very diverse economies around a set of commitments centered primarily on free trade principles. With one sweep, the partnership could potentially create a uniform set of rules...

Read More »

Trust Between Government, Civil Society Bringing More Transparency and Accountability in Tanzania

By Betel Ezaz, Luciana Debenedetti, and Vieshnavi Rattehalli How can the global development community improve governmental transparency and accountability? This week, civil society actors and partners are gathering in Bogota to consider this question, and specifically, the role of civil society in promoting positive change while spurring accountable practices and institutions. Chemonics’ projects often engage local actors in strengthening accountability. Through these efforts, we have found that...

Read More »

What the Paris Agreement Means for the Sustainable Development Goals

The signing of the Paris Climate Agreement today, on Earth Day, represents a global consensus that climate change has, and will continue, to fundamentally alter our natural systems and challenge our way of life unless we take collective and measured steps towards a carbon neutral path. Significantly, it comes on the heels of another monumental international agreement that recognizes the importance of climate change – the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Climate change and poverty are...

Read More »

4 Recommendations for “Thinking and Working Politically” on Local Governance Projects

As Sharon van Pelt argued in her recent blog post, politics are an inescapable reality for any international development project and must be factored into project design and implementation. The “thinking and working politically” concept is catching on, and more development practitioners are using political economy analysis to understand national-level politics in the countries where they work. Projects can benefit from these studies, but we also need to dig deeper to understand politics at the...

Read More »

In Focus: Responding to Floods in Georgia

After severe floods struck the Tianeti region of Georgia, many farmers lost their crops and animal feed — and along with it, their livelihoods. In response to the disaster, the USAID New Economic Opportunities Initiative (NEO) provided multi-mineral feed blocks to the farmer pictured above and others to sustain their livestock throughout the winter. To encourage long-term growth in rural Georgian communities, NEO encouraged governments, businesses, and individuals to create community-level...

Read More »

The Power of Artistic Creativity in Preventing Electoral Violence in Côte d’Ivoire

This post was originally published by the Alliance for Peacebuilding and is cross-posted with permission. Chemonics is honored to be an Alliance for Peacebuilding member organization. The escalation of violence in Côte d’Ivoire after the disputed 2010 presidential election led to the worst humanitarian crisis in the country’s history. Violence devastated families, with an estimated 3,000 deaths, numerous arrests, and hundreds of thousands forced to flee as internally displaced persons or...

Read More »

Think Your Project Isn't Political? Think Again.

All changes and reforms are driven by interests and incentives. We generally understand this and, therefore, we try through our projects to foster positive incentives and collective interests that lead to the change we want to see. Sounds fairly straightforward, but clearly we know it is not, regardless of if we work in agriculture, climate change, health, education, or democracy and governance. Politics – that conflict and struggle for power – permeates the development activities we undertake in...

Read More »

Smallholder Salvation: Promoting Crop Insurance among Smallholder Farmers in Uganda

According to USAID’s recently released “Guide to the Use of Digital Financial Services in Agriculture,” there are an estimated 1.5 billion smallholder farmers worldwide producing approximately 80 percent of the global food supply, who together face an estimated $430 billion shortfall in critical financial services that are needed to support production. In Uganda, where smallholder farmers are responsible for 70 percent of total agricultural production, the Feed the Future Uganda...

Read More »

Business Is for Kids Too: What Business Leaders Are Teaching Young Students in Georgia

By Indira Amiranashvili and Nikoloz Chachkhiani Is business just for adults? In many countries, the business community’s involvement in education is limited to the secondary or post-secondary levels. Under USAID’s Georgia Primary Education (G-PriEd) program, however, we are trying another approach: engaging local businesses in primary education (Grades 1-6) with the goal of equipping children with basic business skills that will help them realize their full potential as adults. There are many...

Posted in: Education and Youth
Read More »

Now Is the Time: Let's End TB in Ukraine

By Kartlos Kankadze, Mariia Dolynska, and Viktoriia Gultai The theme of World TB Day this year, "Unite to End TB," reflects the World Health Organization's (WHO's) End TB Strategy, which recently replaced the Stop TB Strategy and corresponds to the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). End TB sets an ambitious agenda between now and 2035, targeting a 95 percent reduction in number of TB-related deaths, 90 percent reduction in TB incidence rate, and zero families facing catastrophic costs due...

Posted in: Health
Read More »

World Water Day: Closing the Skills Gap for Better Water, Better Jobs in Water-Scarce Countries

Nearly all jobs are related to water. The UN emphasizes that sustainable development is contingent on adequate quality and quantity for public health and agricultural and economic development. Climate change strategies depend on the thousands of people who work in water to help transform societies by properly managing and operating utilities. While safe drinking water, sanitation, and wastewater management are crucial determinants for sustainable development, the UN has identified the need to...

Read More »

Mobile Money Promotes Messages of Peace in Cote d’Ivoire

This post was originally published by the Better Than Cash Alliance and is cross-posted with permission. Chemonics is a proud member of the alliance. Many Ivoirians were concerned that the 2015 presidential elections would lead to renewed conflict, particularly after the violence surrounding the elections of 2010. One successful peace-promoting initiative in the country used radio broadcasts to share messages about reconciliation and the need for ongoing peace during the election period. Payments...

Posted in: Strategic Solutions
Read More »

Benefiting Equally from Land – Reaching Women Before It’s Too Late

The timing, approach, and pace of land reform and collective farm restructuring throughout the former Soviet republics has varied dramatically – and in many places is still ongoing. Whether government chose to privatize land, guarantee land use rights, or keep the status quo of state ownership, land and access to it remains critical for millions of citizens who rely on the land for their livelihoods. Land challenges faced by those throughout Europe and Eurasia is very similar to tens of millions...

Read More »

This Land is My Land: Securing Land Rights for Vulnerable Groups Through Responsible Governance

This week, hundreds of the world’s leading land rights scholars, practitioners, and governors will convene in our nation’s capital for the World Bank Land and Poverty Conference. The theme of this year’s conference is “Scaling up Responsible Land Governance,” and conference-goers will join forces to develop clear pathways for “working at scale, mainstreaming innovations, and sustaining investments in land governance.” This month also marks another significant event in land rights history, as more...

Read More »

Teacher Learning Circles: A Locally Owned Complement to Coaching

By Emet Mohr and Paige Morency Notario Coaching is a welcomed response to the need for active and continuous teacher professional development, which is linked to student achievement gains. Coaching provides significant short-term impact on instruction, but comes with potential long-term sustainability issues due to its high price tag and possible lack of local ownership. Teacher learning circles (TLCs) can serve as a promising addition to the existing coaching model by addressing these two...

Posted in: Education and Youth
Read More »

Examining Gender Parity on International Women’s Day

By Amelda Zotter and JoAnna Lipari International Women's Day has been celebrated around the world since the early 1900s. Originally, its aim was to provide a forum for women to campaign for equality and guarantee their human rights. Over the years, International Women’s Day has turned into a time to reflect on progress made, continue to call for change, and celebrate acts of courage by ordinary women who have played an extraordinary role in the history of their countries and communities. The theme...

Read More »

Radical Transparency: 3 Benefits of Formative Assessment in Promoting Student Learning

By Sarah Grausz and Nikita Soman Education is a fundamental building block for human development and a vital precursor for a country’s overall growth and advancement. When countries prioritize the provision of high-quality primary education, they experience long-term positive correlations in workforce development, economic growth, life expectancy, and democracy and governance processes. USAID’s Education Strategy reflects this fact through a strong commitment to improving early grade reading...

Posted in: Education and Youth
Read More »

Reading Is Thinking: Using Read-Alouds for Comprehensive Literacy Instruction

By Kathryn Camp and Laura Conrad Phonics teaches kids the most basic building blocks of literacy: how to read and pronounce the letters, letter groups, and syllables that come together to create meaning. But phonics-based education for children can and should be more than learning to recognize words. When coupled with interactive exercises, learning to read can unlock children’s imaginations and intellects, and spur critical thinking skills that bring lifelong benefits. Read-alouds can be...

Posted in: Education and Youth
Read More »