# #

Gender Mainstreaming and Integration: 3 Themes for Ensuring Impact in Social and Cultural Norms

By Debora Freitas López and Dr. Kamden Hoffmann

The importance of gender mainstreaming and integration

The disparities between men and women have resulted in women often bearing the burden of development needs, and as a result, gaining fewer benefits from development interventions. Yet, we know that improving access to health and education for girls will contribute to better child, maternal, and family health outcomes, such as reduced domestic violence as well as improved nutrition and under five mortality rates, resulting in increased productivity and incomes. Promoting gender equality is necessary to achieving the 2030 sustainable development agenda and addressing these challenges. Gender is integrated into the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), specifically Goal 5 that calls for achievement of gender equality and empowerment of all women and girls. Gender mainstreaming and integration are used to address social and cultural norms related to gender equality, equity, and empowerment that are encountered as part of social and behavior change (SBC) approaches and interventions. These strategies can ensure that gender perspectives of both men and women are considered in a balanced way and integrated into organizational activities, such as policy development; advocacy; resource allocation; and planning, implementation, and monitoring of programs and projects with the goal of impacting social and cultural norms.

The following three themes can help us better understand the current knowledge and practices related to gender mainstreaming and integration, and bring us closer to understanding how SBC processes can promote gender equality and strengthen program implementation.

1. Meaningful engagement of men and women

The issue: Social expectations and gender stereotyping have a direct effect on the well-being of men and women since in many cases social and behavioral norms dictate what they should and should not do. For example, cultural beliefs that women should not be not allowed to access health resources on their own makes them vulnerable to diseases. Conversely, the cultural belief that it is not masculine to seek health care results in men having exposure to unnecessary pain and discomfort. Empowering women does not mean promoting women’s power over men, nor does it imply losses for men. Rather, men must be involved as allies in SBC interventions as gender equality is not possible without the support of men regarding their attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors.

What needs to be done: Evidence shows that the inclusion of men in SBC program activities results in programs with a greater chance of success in changing or decreasing harmful behavior and beliefs. This has been evident in programs that target sexual and reproductive health; maternal, newborn, and child health; violence against women; and health-seeking behaviors of men. SBC programs that seek to empower women must work to increase men’s participation in eliminating barriers to equality. Engagement of men and boys is a necessary element of gender transformative approaches for sustained change.

2. Improving economic growth

The issue: Gender inequalities are costly to the economy and development of countries; these inequalities undermine productivity, trade performance, and women’s capacity to contribute to the global economy. Many women are still discriminated against and exploited, and as a result are underpaid, insecure, and poverty-stricken. Less education and business training among female entrepreneurs also reduces their productivity. For example, in most developing countries, women play a major role in agricultural production. However, they have limited or no access to important assets such as land, labor, technology, credit, and capital, and their wages represent only 70 to 90 percent (or less) of men’s wages.

What needs to be done: Promoting and shifting norms to accept workplace equality among men and women can ensure economic empowerment. Women’s empowerment through increased job opportunities can boost a country’s economy. UN Women suggests partnering with programs that enable women to secure decent jobs, access resources, and influence public policies that mainly target women with a rural background and low skill sets. One successful model is USAID’s approach to integrating gender issues into agricultural value chains. For example, the Rwandan government used this approach to facilitate women’s business registration, by offering hours that accommodate women’s schedules; hiring women staff; and providing ways to help cash-constrained women register businesses.

3. Health inequality and gender

The issue: Several areas in health (i.e. reproductive health, HIV and other communicable diseases, family planning, and childcare) require gender integration and mainstreaming to ensure adequate preventive care and treatment for men and women. Acute and chronic health conditions among both genders can be reduced largely through addressing health inequality caused by social and cultural norms. Among women, low socio-economic status, limited mobility, lack of decision-making power, gender-based violence, and early marriage contribute to increased risk of maternal mortality. Another source of disparity is access to health care, especially among poorer women who do not seek care due to time and social constraints, an inability to be the decision-maker about their health, and limited access to facilities.

What needs to be done: Gender mainstreaming in health care should include recognition of different risk factors for both genders; collection of gender-specific data to inform health policy; a sound health financing system; recognition and development of a process to address the socioeconomic and cultural factors causing health disparities; and guaranteeing provision of high-quality health care services and essential medicines for both genders. A 2007 World Health Organization review showed that community outreach, mass media campaigns, and mobilization have been proven effective in influencing behavioral changes in these areas. Interventions involve SBC among both men and women are critical in addressing health inequality caused due to gender differences.

So what’s next?

These three themes are not exhaustive; there is still much work to do to better understand how to apply gender mainstreaming and best practices for integrating gender into SBC programming.

  • Consider how gender mainstreaming is conducted in various sectors. An analysis of gender mainstreaming in different sectors could inform development professionals of best practices related to their area of expertise or reveal practices that could potentially be replicated in another technical area. An example is the work in agricultural value chains; while it is recognized that women must be empowered to participate in value chains, further research may determine the best action steps to ensure this is achieved.

  • Agree on a more widely accepted definition of gender-transformative programs. Specific criteria or standards to determine if a program or policy is gender transformative would enable for better streamlining across sectors, including streamlined indicators and standards.

  • Improve and adapt frameworks for developing gender analysis, monitoring, and evaluation tools specific to each sector. We should consider how programs practically apply gender analyses and integrate gender step-by-step throughout a program cycle. A review of organizational policies might also better inform gender mainstreaming practices for organizations who seek to integrate gender into their culture and human resources.

Debora Freitas López is a director and the SBC point person for Chemonics’ Global Health Division, and serves as co-chair for CORE Group’s SBC Working Group. Dr. Kamden Hoffmann is president of Insight Health, a women-owned small business consulting firm focused on innovative SBC and community-engaged participatory approaches. Their conclusions are drawn from a desk review of existing literature, which is forthcoming.

Leave a Comment

Can Islamic Banking Increase Afghans’ Access to Finance?

The World Bank estimates that only 10 percent of Afghans hold an account with a financial institution, far below the average of 22 percent for low-income nations. The reasons for this are numerous: many Afghans report mistrust of banks, some lack the proper documentation to access financial services, and those living outside major population centers find great difficulty in even traveling to a bank. Of particular note from the World Bank’s Global Findex is that nearly one-quarter of those...

Read More »

3 Questions with Bassey Archibong: Inclusive Development in Nigeria

Bassey Archibong is the director of household economic strengthening for USAID's Maximizing Agricultural Revenue and Key Enterprise in Targeted Sites (MARKETS II) project in Nigeria. The project aims to improve the performance, income, nutrition, and food security of poor Nigerian rural farmers or smallholders in an environmentally friendly manner. Why is social inclusion important for the development of Nigeria? In Nigeria, 68 percent of the population lives in poverty, living on less than $1.25...

Read More »

3 Questions with Kelly Brooks: On the Historic Colombian Peace Process

Kelly Brooks is chief of party for the USAID Human Rights Activity (HRA) in Colombia. HRA supports the Colombian government and civil society to foster respect for human rights and protect vulnerable populations. The Colombian government is negotiating a peace accord with the FARC guerrilla group after 50 years of conflict. What are the biggest challenges that the demobilization of the FARC presents, and how can the donor community support Colombia in overcoming those challenges? The FARC has...

Read More »

Fail Fast, Succeed Sooner: Why Investing in Innovation Is Worth the Risk

It has become increasingly trendy in international development to look to Silicon Valley and the tech world’s start-up culture for inspiration in making our programs more “innovative.” Inspired by the pace at which the tech world can turn an idea into products and staples of everyday life, we aspiring innovators of international development look to their example in turning ideas into social change. Posing the question what does innovation look like in international development, Chemonics and...

Posted in: Strategic Solutions
Read More »

Research and Action to Promote Regional Trade in South Asia

The United States’ economic future is inextricably linked to Asia. A full quarter of the goods and services exported by the United States are bound for Asia, and about 30 percent of our imports come from the region. In addition, exports to Asia support more than a million American jobs. As such, the United States is committed to strengthening its economic relationship with Asia and ensuring that the benefits are shared broadly. This shared prosperity is founded on sustainable, inclusive growth...

Read More »

3 Lessons in Empowering Youth Around the World

August 12 is International Youth Day, an exciting occasion meant for governments and intuitions to draw attention to youth issues worldwide. More than half the world’s population is now under the age of 30 years old, and it is critical to review successes in working with youth populations to empower young people as tomorrow’s leaders. Below are three strands of success I found in Chemonics work with youth in workforce development, livelihood, and agripreneurship initiatives in 70 countries...

Posted in: Education and Youth
Read More »

Looking Back on #AIDS2016: Self-Testing May Be a Revolution for HIV Patients

Each biennial International AIDS Conference is eventually remembered for the broad themes coming out of a long, exciting, and energizing week of presentations, networking, and protests. A key theme of this year’s conference in Durban, South Africa, was patient empowerment.  PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis) was a rallying cry to help the most vulnerable populations such as gay men, female sex workers, and intravenous drug users take more control of their efforts to avoid infection. We heard from...

Posted in: Health
Read More »

The Next Mother I Meet

The slender young woman was slumped on the metal chair, her malnourished baby in her arms. “I have no milk,” she said, pulling her breast out of her shirt. “I just give him water because it is so hot.” As a Peace Corps volunteer in those days, I struggled in my halting Hausa to explain to the mother how important exclusive breastfeeding was for her infant. My counterpart, a Nigerien nurse in our rural clinic outside of Mayahi, perfunctorily squeezed her breast with his gloved hands, producing...

Posted in: Health
Read More »

When to Use (and Not Use) an SMS Survey

With mobile phone penetration rates exceeding 80 percent in many developing countries, development organizations have a new and exciting way of communicating with and collecting information from beneficiaries and stakeholders. Paired with the growing emphasis on evidence-based decisions, collecting data through SMS surveys has generated a significant following and an array of tools for design and deployment. For many good reasons, the development community is jumping on the bandwagon. But before...

Read More »

Big Goals Need Measurement

Late last year, I know many of you joined me in applauding as the United Nations formally adopted the Sustainable Development Goals, an unprecedented step that aligns development agencies and stakeholders worldwide around a single platform. The goals themselves are ambitious and sweeping — ending poverty and hunger, for instance, are goals we have been working toward for decades. But we need that ambition to unite us and drive us. To help bring these goals fully into development work on...

Read More »

3 Questions with Tony Savelli: Saving Lives Through Health Supply Chains

Tony Savelli is the project director of the Global Health Supply Chain – Procurement and Supply Management (GHSC-PSM) Project. GHSC-PSM is working to ensure uninterrupted supplies of health commodities reach patients around the world by transforming supply chains at the global and country level. What would you like to see GHSC-PSM accomplish over the next five years? In other words, how do you define success for GHSC-PSM? On any project where health commodities are involved, the ultimate goal...

Posted in: Health
Read More »

Meet 3 Animals that Tell Us About the Health of the Philippines' Forests

Some animals that depend on the forest tell us a great deal about the health of their environment and the effectiveness of efforts to preserve it. In the Philippines, environmentalists and government officials are using a new system called the LAWIN Forest and Biodiversity Protection System to monitor the state of forests in an unprecedented way – among other things, collecting data on the presence of forest-dependent species.  The Philippines' vanishing forests Like many developing countries, the...

Read More »

Achieving 90-90-90 – with Lessons from the 90s

This post also appeared on the Digital Hub of the 2016 International AIDS Conference. Last week I sat in a workshop about expanding access to treatment for all people living with HIV, regardless of their clinical stage or CD4 count, and remembered my early years working on HIV programs in sub-Saharan Africa. As I reflected on how far we’ve come, I thought about some of the biggest lessons I have learned over my career and how we can apply them to challenges going forward. When I started out, the...

Posted in: Health
Read More »

3 Questions with Mozambican Mayors: Local Perspectives on Climate Change Resilience

Manuel de Araujo, Tagir Carimo, and Rui Chong Saw are the mayors of Quelimane, Pemba, and Nacala — three coastal cities in Mozambique that are struggling with the effects of climate change. The mayors are collaborating with USAID/Mozambique’s Coastal City Adaptation Project, a five-year project aiming to increase the cities’ capacity to effectively respond to the impacts of climate change.  Do you feel that climate change is impacting your city? If so, what is the day-to-day impact? Tagir Carimo:...

Read More »

Why Investing in Teenage Girls Matters

By Kelly Cronen, Amelda Zotter, and Marcela de Campos World Population Day on July 11 reminds us to focus on population trends and discuss the most pertinent issues facing our population today. This year’s theme is “Investing in Teenage Girls,” and it serves to highlight the importance of empowering the largest generation of girls in history. According to the United Nations Population Fund, there are 600 million adolescent girls in the world today with unique needs, challenges, and aspirations for...

Read More »

To Encourage Data Use, Focus on Visualization

In the new context of thousands upon thousands of terabytes of data and millions of database rows, monitoring and evaluation (M&E) professionals find ourselves faced with a new reality. We are now expected to not only understand the data ourselves, but then to transform the raw data to something our audiences can easily use for decision-making. This imperative comes directly from the idea of utilization-focused evaluation, which requires that we ask ourselves how the data will be used and by...

Read More »

3 Questions with Rosa Jimenez: Prosecuting Criminals in the Dominican Republic

Rosa Jimenez is deputy chief of party for the USAID Dominican Republic Criminal Justice System Strengthened Project (CJSSP). The project is designed to improve the island nation’s judicial institutions, expedite prosecutions, and improve vulnerable groups’ access to legal protection. The Dominican Republic has one of the highest crime rates in the Caribbean. In your view, what is the most pressing challenge facing the country's criminal justice system? The essence of the problem is our low...

Read More »

5 Surprising Facts About Indonesia — and Why They Matter for Global Development

There are several countries that often come up when people talk about international development and the global economy, countries that need not be listed because you can probably already name them. Indonesia is not usually among them, but as these five facts show, there is a lot at stake in this large and incredibly diverse country's development. Fact 1: Indonesia is a lot bigger than you think.  Source: The World Factbook It’s difficult to grasp just how large a country is, in part because we have...

Posted in: Chemonics
Read More »

How Mobile Money Can Cut Down on Corruption in Afghanistan

By Andrew Hull, Elise Sidamon-Eristoff Increasingly over the last several years, using mobile money as a tool for spurring economic growth and development has been heralded as a laudable development endeavor, and rightfully so. Those familiar with this narrative will quickly point to the case of Kenya’s M-PESA. From media coverage to academic studies, the rapid growth of mobile money services in Kenya has been one of great appeal and widely encouraged as a model for replication. In Afghanistan,...

Read More »